Round Up of Locally-Owned Pizza Spots in Tallahassee

By Cristi McKee | Photo: Momo’s Pizza – Market Street

Tallahassee is abundant in pizza joints, plenty of which are owned by our neighbors in Tallahassee. Check out this ever-growing round up of locally-owned pizza spots here in town.

Midtown Pies — Selling unique pizzas, draft beer, and sandwiches, Midtown Pies is the Midtown location for Gaines Street Pies. Find out what their menu has to offer, here.

Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana — Located in FSU College Town, Isabella’s offers Neopolitan-style pizza, salad, and more. Check out their menu, here.

Brooklyn Pizza — This pizza restaurant offers New York-style pizza right here in the Capitol City. Located in downtown Tallahassee, you can check them out and order online, here.

Centrale Pizza, Parm, & Bar — Centrale is located in FSU College Town and offers a casual and fun dining experience. The Italian cuisine spots serves “crazy good pizza,” wine, and classic Italian appetizers. 

Dave’s Pizza Garage — Known for its pizza and wings, Dave’s Pizza Garage also offers cookies, BLT’s, and gluten-free options. Check out their menu, and order online, here.

Milano Pizzeria — Serving New York-style gourmet pizzas, wings, strombolis, calzones, and other authentic Italian fare, Milano Pizzeria’s extensive online menu can be found online, here.

Village Pizza & Pasta — This Italian restaurant serves New York-style pizza made in real brick ovens, offers seafood options and pasta, and is located in northern Tallahassee. Find their online menu, here.

Munchie’s Pizza — Munchie’s is located downtown and is in a prime spot for college students at FAMU, TCC, and FSU. Serving affordable bites, including pizza, subs, salads, garlic knots, and more, you can order online, here.

Doughlicious Pizza — Featuring pizza, wings, subs, crepes, and more, Doughlicious Pizza stays open late, offers delivery, and offers a number of unique Italian food options. Find them online, here.

Park’s Pizza Kitchen — Park’s Pizza Kitchen uses organic, all-natural, locally-sourced ingredients to make New York-style pizzas. Their creative and unique menu can be found online, here. 

Decent Pizza — Decent Pizza, located in downtown Tallahassee, offers pizza, sandwiches, and more, and was voted Best Pizza in Tallahassee. Find them online, here.

Momo’s Pizza — Famous for their humongous pizzas with “slices as big as your head,” Momo’s offers eclectic and classic pizzas alike, calzones, and draft beers. With 2 locations in Tallahassee, you can check them out on Facebook, here.

Gaines Street Pies — Gaines Street Pies has an array of different pizzas, appetizers, and salads, and has 3 locations across town. Check out their menu, here.

Brickyard Pizza — Serving “mouthwatering” pastas and pizzas like, Brickyard also offers calzones, grinders, salads, and more. Find them online, here.

Barnaby’s Family Inn — Barnaby’s has served the Tallahassee community over the past 50 years. Featuring fresh ingredients, “master” pizzas and more, you can find their extensive menu online, here.

Do you have a favorite pizza spot in Tallahassee? Let us know!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s